Skip to main content
Back
Blog

Coolglass two years on: Where are we now?

Tuesday, 17th November 2026
Coolglass two years on: Where are we now?

Speed read

Almost two years have passed since the significant High Court judgment in Coolglass quashing An Bord Pleanála’s (for the purposes of this article, we will refer to the Board by its new name, the Commission) refusal of planning permission for the Coolglass wind farm (see our previous insight here). Earlier this year, the Supreme Court upheld that decision, finding that the Commission had failed in its obligations under s. 15 of the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Act 2015 (as amended) (s. 15), but on narrower grounds than the High Court (see our previous insight here). In this article, we consider why the judicial review was brought, the approaches of the High Court and Supreme Court and developments since, including changes at the planning decision-making stage and whether Ireland can still meet its climate and renewable energy targets.

The background: a perfect storm for onshore wind

In 2023 and 2024, renewable energy developers faced two problems at once. First, in the 2021 to 2023 development plan cycle, a number of planning authorities adopted county development plans that designated large areas as ‘not open for consideration’ for wind farms. Second, the Commission became increasingly reluctant to grant permission for wind farms in material contravention of those plans.

The consequences were stark. Evidence before the High Court in Coolglass, showed that the average annual approval rate for wind farms, which had run at about 80% between 2017 and 2022, fell to about 60% in 2023 and to 30% in the first nine months of 2024. On that trajectory, Ireland could not meet its target of 9 GW of onshore wind by 2030. In 2023 and 2024, not a single wind farm was considered of sufficient strategic importance to justify a material contravention of any development plan.

It was against this background that the wind farm developer brought the judicial review proceedings in Coolglass, as a last resort, to test whether s. 15 could set some limits on the Commission’s refusal of wind farm permissions.

From the High Court to the Supreme Court

In January 2025, the High Court quashed the Commission's refusal of permission. The judgment emphasised the scale and urgency of the climate crisis, citing the State's own submissions that climate change is the single greatest threat facing humanity and that the 2021 amendments made to s. 15 were intended to reflect this. Drawing on Ireland's domestic targets and its obligations under EU and international law, the Court adopted a purposive interpretation of s. 15: the Commission and other relevant bodies must act in conformity with climate plans and objectives unless it is impracticable to do so.

On appeal, the Supreme Court upheld the order quashing the refusal, but on a materially different basis. It accepted that s. 15 considerably strengthens the obligation on public bodies, including the Commission, to perform their functions consistently with the specified climate objectives insofar as practicable, describing the amendment as a statutory reset and "a form of climate sense check".

The Supreme Court also confirmed that the s. 15 obligation on public bodies is outcome-oriented rather than merely procedural and, in principle, enforceable by the courts. However, it rejected the idea that s. 15 requires a simple climate-friendly "go" or climate-unfriendly "stop" test, recognising that climate objectives will not automatically determine the outcome of every planning decision. Notably, the Court observed that climate considerations already "permeate" and are "woven into the detail of the planning code". On that basis, development plans and planning decisions made under them can be presumed to be consistent with s. 15 (although this is a rebuttable presumption).

Trickle down of national climate policy to development plans

The Supreme Court's observation that climate considerations “permeate the planning code” raises the question of to what degree county development plans actually reflect current climate objectives. The current county development plans, adopted between 2021 and 2023, predate the Climate Action Plan 2024 and later climate policy. Climate action plans are meant to be updated annually, while development plans run on a six-year cycle (moving to ten years under the Planning and Development Act 2024). Keeping pace with national policy also places a real resourcing burden on planning authorities. The next development plan cycle under the 2024 Act may be an opportunity to close this gap.

After Coolglass

In the nine months since the Supreme Court’s decision, the High Court has applied Coolglass to both renewable projects (Keogh and Ors -v- An Coimisiún Pleanála and Anor [2026] IEHC 339) and emissions-generating projects (Doyle and Ors -v- An Coimisiún Pleanála and Ors [No. 3] [2026] IEHC 156 and Friends of the Irish Environment CLG -v- An Coimisiún Pleanála and Ors [2026] IEHC 205). The interpretation of s. 15 now appears fairly settled, and indeed this was noted by the Supreme Court recently in Doyle when it refused leave to the applicants to appeal the High Court’s decision.

There has also been a clear shift at the decision-making stage. Following the High Court judgment, the Commission’s approval rate for wind farms returned to around 90% in 2025 and Commission figures up to September 2026 show a grant rate of approximately 85% for renewable energy projects (including solar) and around 75% for onshore wind. Measured against the problem the wind farm developer set out to address, Coolglass has had a significant effect.

Planning approval is, however, only part of the picture. Despite there being 7.7 GW of installed renewable capacity in Ireland at the end of 2025, new renewable capacity is being added far more slowly than the approximately 2 GW a year that the Climate Change Advisory Council estimates is required to meet 2030 targets. Part of that gap is likely to reflect the low approval rates of 2023 and 2024 working through the system.

Even where permission is granted, the bottleneck has moved downstream. When launching its Onshore Wind Action Plan in September 2026, Wind Energy Ireland stated that more than 3,000 MW of onshore wind with planning permission was awaiting grid connection. Some projects, particularly in counties Mayo and Donegal, have been told to expect wait times of five years or more. Grid capacity and connection delays now require urgent attention.

Looking ahead

National planning policy has yet to catch up with Ireland’s renewable energy targets. There is still no National Planning Statement on Wind Energy and the 2006 Wind Energy Guidelines have not been replaced. It also remains to be seen how the renewable capacity allocations under the National Planning Framework and the Regional Spatial and Economic Strategies will be stepped down into county development plans.

The climate context is also tightening. Ireland has now entered its second carbon budget period (2026 to 2030), which caps emissions at 200 MtCO₂eq. The Environmental Protection Agency’s May 2026 projections indicate that, even with full implementation of planned measures, emissions will fall by only up to 25% by 2030 compared with 2018 levels, well short of the legally binding 51% target, and that this budget will be exceeded by approximately 53–82 MtCO₂eq. The budgets are likely to tighten further after 2030. In December 2024, the Climate Change Advisory Council proposed a third carbon budget of 160 MtCO₂eq for 2031–2035 and a provisional fourth budget of 120 MtCO₂eq for 2036–2040. Against that backdrop, publication of the Climate Action Plan 2026 (CAP26), which must set out the actions needed to comply with these budgets, has been delayed by 11 months, although it is reportedly expected later this month. Renewables are not only an emissions issue but also a matter of energy security. According to the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI), imports met over 78% of Ireland’s energy needs in 2025, well above the EU average of 57.3%, leaving the country exposed to geopolitical risk and price volatility, with direct consequences for affordability.

Finally, in its Coolglass judgment, the Supreme Court observed that the State could adopt more granular national climate objectives in future Climate Action Plans, which would narrow the range of decisions capable of being consistent with s. 15. If CAP26 or later plans are more detailed, the courts may well have to revisit Coolglass.

Key takeaways

  • S. 15 imposes a legally enforceable, outcome-oriented obligation, but it only operates as a “form of climate sense check” to ensure decisions of public sector bodies are all aligned with climate objectives. The obligation is not more prescriptive than that, and ‘consistency’ with s.15 will generally allow for a range of lawful outcomes.
  • The presumption that development plans comply with s. 15 may be open to challenge where those plans predate current climate policy, particularly ahead of the next plan cycle under the 2024 Act.
  • Approval rates for wind farms have recovered substantially since Coolglass, but grid capacity and gaps in national policy are now the main obstacles to the 2030 targets.
  • More granular national climate objectives in CAP26 or later plans could narrow the range of consistent decisions and prompt further litigation.

Listen to the Podcast

For a more detailed discussion on these issues, listen to our podcast, After Coolglass: Is Planning Climate-Ready?, where Marika Williams and Alan Roberts explore how the Coolglass decision has reshaped planning for renewable energy projects and what it means for the future of climate policy, planning and grid infrastructure.

For more information, please contact Alan Roberts, Partner, Marika Williams, Lawyer, Rachel Kemp, Senior Practice Development Lawyer, or your usual contact in the  Environmental & Planning team.

  • Picture of Rachel Kemp
    Rachel Kemp
    Senior Practice Development Lawyer, Disputes & Investigations
    Rachel Kemp is a  Senior Practice Development Lawyer in the firm’s Litigation & Dispute Resolution Department.She is an experienced commercial litigator, having previously trained and worked in a large commercial law firm.
  • Picture of Alan Roberts
    Alan Roberts
    Partner, Environmental & Planning
  • Picture of Marika Williams
    Marika Williams
    Lawyer, Environmental & Planning